Monday, June 13, 2011

All-male, celibate Catholic priesthood is an embarrassing relic

By John Veal,
Kansas City Star

Should Bishop Robert Finn resign? It would be a rare example of accountability. But this question, I believe, is largely irrelevant to the central problem behind the ongoing priestly sexual abuse scandals.

I am a lifelong, devout Catholic and a historian. To me, the central problem is not the fact that a relatively few priests have sexually abused children, evil as that is. Priests are prone to the same failings as everyone else. Like anyone else, they should face appropriate criminal penalties and civil liabilities.

Neither is the real issue those bishops who have been negligent in confronting the problem or complicit in covering it up. They too must be held legally accountable.

Most absurd of all, the main problem is not the cultural upheaval of the 1960s. A recent study blamed in part the “patterns of increased deviance in society” at that time. This implies the existence of a golden age of priestly celibacy that never existed.

As I see it, the central problem behind the ongoing clerical abuse scandal is the all-male, celibate priesthood. It is an embarrassing holdover from the Middle Ages.

Da Vinci Code aside, real historical evidence shows that women’s roles in the Catholic Church were increasingly restricted as the early church became established. At the same time, the view of all sexuality as evil crept into the church. The origins of this sex-denying ethic were cultural, not scriptural.

Other issues, such as the inheritance of church property for the many priests with families, also led to the church increasingly to insist on absolute priestly celibacy.

The result today is a closed society of men held to a standard Jesus never established, the apostles did not follow, and many fine priests cannot meet.

There is simply no valid scriptural or theological basis for the celibate male clergy. Almost all other Christian churches rejected celibacy centuries ago. Many have also admitted women to their clergy. Yet Rome still condemns these changes as strongly as it once condemned Galileo’s proof of a sun-centered universe.

Would a Catholic clergy composed of men and women, single and married, prevent clerical sexual abuse? Of course not. But can anyone doubt that women priests would be less likely to protect their deviant peers?

Just as Pope Urban silenced Galileo but not his truth, Rome today has banned discussion of a female priesthood. Yet the “sense of the faithful” has moved beyond the sexism and sexual dread of Church leadership.

Bishop Finn, your people are angry. Your many good priests are humiliated. I do not call on you to resign or to implement weak reforms of the current system. I call on you to speak out for sweeping reform of the priesthood — for women’s ordination and optional celibacy. That would be more powerful than any apology.

John Veal is a lifelong Catholic and a history teacher. He lives in Kansas City.


Norma Villarreal said...

Perhaps changing the all-male, celibate Catholic priesthood would be a solution to the problem of clergy abuse. How many 'relatively few priests' have sexually abused children? How many victims has each predator clergy created in a lifetime? Rome has some housecleaning to do.

Faisal said...

Hello dear in Christ ,

I Greet you in the name of our lord Jesus name .first of all i would like to tell you all about me ..well my name is Faisal i am from Pakistan and i am Christian and i am working here for God in Pakistan ..we have a ministry here . we doing missionary works here ..we working with Orphans children . we helping Orphans for , food , shelter , clothings and everything here . we giving them everything what they have need i am very glad that God is using me for his work and God is working in my life and i am thankful to God very much that God is using me for his special kids they are not Orphans i felt they are is God special children i would like to tell you that i found your blog by search i like your work very much .you are doing very nice work ..i would like to say you please contact with me .i would like to contact with you ..i hope you know that Pakistan is a Muslim country and its very hard to be Christian in a Muslim country ..i am working here for God very hardly my friend therefore we need your prayers and some support if you like if you like to do help our Orphans so please contact with me ..they are kids is also praying that God will provide them some helping hands please keep in touch with me ..i am waiting for your back message i hope i will hear from you soon .God bless you and God be with you and your family always ..
your brother in Christ ,
Faisal Saleem .
From ( Pakistan )
Email ;
website :

Anonymous said...

Not only Catholic or celibate male priests are abusing children sexually but here in India a pastor was arrested in Bangalore for sexually exploiting minor girls at a study centre following a complaint by his wife.I hope like many young girls in Bangalore decided to voice out, we can collectively voice out to end male chauvinism of priesthood

LaMiaVerita said...

While you can blame the "all-male celibate priesthood" policy for the sexual abuse that's occurred the Holy See does not see that as the particular problem. Actually, they don't give an opinion on the cause and feel this predator behavior can be cured. It's of course a grave sin as well.

As far as considering the numbers "a relative few," I don't consider 5% few in any respect. (Ref: A Perspective on Clergy Sexual Abuse by Dr. Thomas Plante of Stanford University)

Whatever our opinions are I think we'd all have to agree that the way the church mishandled this scandal was by ignoring it until an attempt at a solution was forced upon them by the public attention it deserved. Even this attention was considered excessive by the church.